Media Konservasi is strongly committed to maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record. This policy explains when and how a published or submitted article may be retracted, withdrawn, corrected, removed, or replaced.

Follows COPE Retraction Guidelines

Article Retraction

An article may be considered for retraction on the following grounds:

Substantial error

Compelling evidence that the findings are unreliable and the conclusions may be invalid, whether due to misconduct (e.g., data fabrication) or honest error (e.g., miscalculation or experimental error).

Redundant publication

The results have been published elsewhere without proper cross-referencing, permission, or justification.

Ethical concerns

Plagiarism (using another person's ideas, processes, results, or words without attribution, including confidential review material) or inappropriate authorship.

Retraction process
  1. NotificationAn article that may need retraction is brought to the attention of the journal editor.
  2. AssessmentThe editor follows the COPE flowcharts step by step, including evaluating any response from the author.
  3. Ethics reviewBefore any action is taken, the editor's findings are submitted to the Ethics Advisory Board to ensure a consistent, best-practice approach.
  4. DecisionThe final decision is communicated to the author and, where necessary, to other relevant parties such as the author's institution.
  5. Retraction noticeA retraction statement is posted online and published in the next available issue of the journal.
Copyright does not include the right to retract. Authors who retain copyright of an article cannot retract it on their own after publication. Protecting the integrity of the scientific record comes first, and COPE's Retraction Guidelines apply.

Article Withdrawal

Withdrawal during or after peer review is not permitted. It wastes substantial resources, including the time editors and reviewers have invested in the manuscript and the work of the publisher. Before submitting, authors must confirm their acceptance of the submission checklist.
Requesting a withdrawal. If an author still wishes to withdraw a manuscript, an official letter signed by the corresponding author and the head of their institution must be sent to the Editor-in-Chief.

Article Correction

A correction may be issued when:

  • A small part of an otherwise reliable article contains flawed or misleading data, particularly as the result of an honest mistake.
  • The author or contributor list is inaccurate, e.g., a deserving author was omitted or someone who does not meet the authorship criteria was included.
Types of correction
Erratum

A significant error made by the publisher or journal staff, usually during production, that affects the publication record, the article's scientific integrity, or the reputation of the authors or journal.

Publisher correction
Corrigendum

A significant error made by the authors that affects the publication record, the article's scientific integrity, or the reputation of the authors or journal.

Author correction
Addendum

An addition by the authors to resolve inconsistencies, expand on the work, or explain and update information in the main text.

Author addition

The journal editors decide whether a correction is needed and which type to issue, sometimes in consultation with reviewers or Editorial Board members. The handling editor will contact the authors for clarification before a decision is made.

Article Removal

In extremely rare cases, a published article may need to be removed from our website. This is only considered when an article:

Is clearly defamatory Infringes others' legal rights Is, or is expected to be, subject to a court order Could pose a significant health risk if acted upon
Kept: the article's metadata, including title and author information.
Replaced: the full content, with a notice that the article was removed for legal reasons.

Article Replacement

If an article could pose a significant health hazard if acted upon, the authors may choose to withdraw the flawed version and replace it with a corrected one. The retraction process above applies, with one difference:

Flawed versionretracted
Retraction noticelinks to the new version and records the document's history
Corrected articlerepublished

Post-Publication Discussion

Publication is not the end of scholarly scrutiny. Media Konservasi provides room for post-publication discussion of its articles, including disputes arising from the peer-review process, rejected comments, and published corrections.

What can be raised
  • Questions or critiques about an article's methods, data, analysis, or interpretation.
  • Possible errors in a published article, including in figures, tables, or references.
  • Concerns about research or publication ethics, such as plagiarism, duplicate publication, or authorship.
How it is handled
  1. Send an emailEmail media.konservasi@apps.ipb.ac.id, stating the title of the article and your comment or concern.
  2. Editorial reviewThe editor assesses the concern, consulting reviewers or Editorial Board members where needed.
  3. Author responseThe authors are informed and given the opportunity to respond.
  4. OutcomeThe editor decides on the appropriate action and informs the parties involved.
No further action

The article stands as published, for example when the concern is resolved through clarification.

Correction

An erratum, corrigendum, or addendum is issued, as described above.

Retraction

The article is retracted following the retraction process and COPE guidelines.

To start a discussion, simply email media.konservasi@apps.ipb.ac.id and mention the title of the article. Please keep discussion constructive and focused on the scholarly content of the article.

Allegations of Research Misconduct

Media Konservasi takes every allegation of research or publication misconduct seriously, whether it concerns a manuscript under review or a published article, and however it reaches the journal, including from whistleblowers or public discussion online. Allegations are handled following the COPE flowcharts.

Examples of misconduct
Data fabrication or falsification Plagiarism Duplicate or redundant publication Image manipulation Authorship misconduct Undisclosed conflicts of interest Citation or peer-review manipulation
How allegations are handled
  1. ReportEmail media.konservasi@apps.ipb.ac.id, stating the title of the article or manuscript, the nature of the concern, and any supporting evidence you have.
  2. Initial assessmentThe Editor-in-Chief checks whether the allegation is specific and supported enough to investigate.
  3. Author responseThe authors are informed of the concern and given a fair opportunity to explain.
  4. InvestigationThe editor follows the relevant COPE flowchart and, where needed, consults the Ethics Advisory Board or contacts the authors' institution.
  5. DecisionThe outcome is communicated to the authors and, where appropriate, to the person who raised the concern.
Confidentiality

The identity of the person raising a concern is kept confidential, and allegations are not discussed publicly while they are being assessed.

Fairness

No conclusion is reached until the authors have had the chance to respond. Raising a concern in good faith is never held against the person who raised it.

Possible outcomes
  • No misconduct found: no further action, and the authors are informed.
  • Minor issue: the authors are asked to clarify, or a correction is published.
  • Serious misconduct: the manuscript is rejected or the article is retracted, and the authors' institution may be notified.
Plagiarism. Authors found to have committed plagiarism are banned from publishing in Media Konservasi, as stated in our Publication Ethics.

Update Information

All updates to articles are communicated through Crossmark. To check whether an article has been updated, click the Crossmark logo on its first page; it shows information about the current version of the article.