Peer Review Process
Media Konservasi uses a double-blind peer review process to evaluate whether a manuscript is suitable for publication. The Editor-in-Chief manages communication with authors and makes the final decision to accept, reject, or request revision.
to publication
Media Konservasi operates two separate systems:
Submission System
Manuscript submission, peer review, revision, copyediting, and layout.
submission2-journal.ipb.ac.id/konservasiPublication System
Publication and indexing of final articles, together with the journal's archive.
journal.ipb.ac.id/konservasi- 1
Submission
Authors submit manuscripts through the Submission System. They must follow the Submission Preparation Checklist, attach the Author Statement Form, and use the manuscript format specified by Media Konservasi (Article Template).
- 2
Administrative Screening & Prequalification
After a manuscript passes administrative screening, the Editor-in-Chief conducts a prequalification review to decide whether it is suitable for further evaluation.
Rejected without review if:- its topic does not fit the scope of Media Konservasi;
- its content does not meet the journal's standards, or lacks novelty, advancement, or consistency; or
- it does not follow the guidelines in the Instruction to Authors.
- 3
Double-Blind Peer Review
Manuscripts that pass prequalification are assessed by at least two qualified peer reviewers, selected by the Editor-in-Chief and Section Editors.
3 weeksConflicting recommendations? The Editor-in-Chief invites a third reviewer or refers the decision to the Editorial Board. - 4
Author Revision & Re-review
Manuscripts that need revision are returned to the authors, who must submit the revised manuscript through the Submission System. If a peer reviewer requests it, the revised manuscript is re-examined, counted from the reviewer's acceptance of the re-review request.
3 weeks revision3 weeks re-review - 5
Section Editor Evaluation
The Editor-in-Chief forwards the revised manuscript to the Section Editor, who checks that the reviewers' suggestions have been addressed and recommends one of three outcomes: return to the authors, acceptance, or rejection.
2 weeksMay be rejected if the authors do not revise as suggested by the reviewers or the Editorial Board, or if their response to the suggestions is inadequate. - 6
Editor-in-Chief Decision
The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision and notifies the authors.
Appeals: Authors may appeal a rejection. The Editor-in-Chief and the relevant Section Editor review the appeal and make a final decision.
- 7
Article Processing Charge (APC)
After the Editor-in-Chief accepts the manuscript, the authors pay the APC.
- 8
Copyediting & Layout
The manuscript is copyedited and laid out in the Submission System.
- 9
Acceptance Letter
The authors receive an acceptance letter stating the issue in which the article will be published.
- 10
Published & Indexed
The final article is published and indexed on journal.ipb.ac.id/konservasi, together with the journal's archive and indexing databases.
Timelines are targets; actual duration may vary.