Effective Altruism, Islamic Philanthropy, and Public Welfare: A Critique
Abstract
Islamic philanthropy is often seen as a major articulation of Islamic principles of wealth redistribution and social justice, especially in rural and peripheral areas. In this mainstream narrative, the economic mandate of Islam is seen from a prism of noblesse oblige and/or reformism, turning the Islamic notion of solidarity into an individualized obligation for charity and almsgiving. This embourgeoisement of Islamic economic ethics overlaps with and embodies the idea of Effective Altruism (EA), a utilitarian practical philosophy of philanthropy for the most pressing social causes which has grown into a gigantic industry-cum-fad of the global capitalist elites. This article presents a critique of EA, EA-adjacent practices of Islamic philanthropy, and alternative economic proposals for rural welfare. To do so, this article uses insights from critical studies of political thought, critical political economy, and solidarity economy literature as an analytical lens in analyzing EA and Islamic philanthropy and formulating a synthesis of Islamic economic ethics and alter-capitalist rural welfare practices and institutions. This paper concludes that Islamic philanthropy and EA have serious limitations in improving rural welfare, especially in Global South countries such as Indonesia, and shows alternative pathways for agrarian justice.
References
Al-Ghamdy, A. (2012, August 15). Zakat and the War Fought for It. Retrieved June 20, 2023, from Saudi Gazette: https://saudigazette.com.sa/article/12440
Alter, C. (2023, March 15). Exclusive: Effective Altruist Leaders Were Repeatedly Warned About Sam Bankman-Fried Years Before FTX Collapsed. Retrieved June 16, 2023, from Time: https://time.com/6262810/sam-bankman-fried-effective-altruism-alameda-ftx/
Anugrah, I. (2019, April 2). Women among the Fishers. Retrieved October 5, 2023, from Indonesia at Melbourne: https://indonesiaatmelbourne.unimelb.edu.au/women-among-the-fishers/
Belay, M., & Mugambe, B. (2021, July 6). Bill Gates Should Stop Telling Africans What Kind of Agriculture Africans Need. Retrieved June 19, 2023, from Scientific American: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/bill-gates-should-stop-telling-africans-what-kind-of-agriculture-africans-need1/
Bernstein, H. (2010). Class Dynamics of Agrarian Change. Halifax: Fernwood Publishing.
Choiruzzad, S. A.-B. (2013, April). More Gain, More Pain: The Development of Indonesia’s Islamic Economy Movement (1980s–2012). Indonesia, 95, 125-172.
Cowen, T. (2015, August 14). Effective Altruism: Where Charity and Rationality Meet. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from The New York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/16/upshot/effective-altruism-where-charity-and-rationality-meet.html
Crary, A. (2021). Against "Effective Altruism". Radical Philosophy, 2(10), 33-43.
Crary, A. (2023). The Toxic Ideology of Longtermism. Radical Philosophy, 2(14), 49-57.
Di Mento, M. (2022, December 30). Bill Gates Made 2022’s Biggest Charitable Donation: $5 billion. Retrieved May 26, 2023, from Los Angeles Times: https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2022-12-30/bill-gates-made-2022s-biggest-charitable-donation-5-billion
Dompet Dhuafa. (2020, October 27). Sejarah Pengelolaan Zakat Pada Masa Khalifah Abu Bakar Asyidiq. Retrieved June 19, 2023, from Dompet Dhuafa: https://www.dompetdhuafa.org/zakat-pada-masa-khalifah-abu-bakar/
Featherstone, L. (2022, February 14). The Political Isn't Personal. Retrieved June 22, 2023, from Jacobin: https://jacobin.com/2022/02/the-political-isnt-personal
Fogg, K. W. (2019). Indonesian Islamic Socialism and its South Asian Roots. Modern Asian Studies, 53(6), 1736-1761.
Fraser, N. (2016, July/August). Contradictions of Capital and Care. New Left Review(100), 99-117.
Gates, B. (2021). How to Avoid a Climate Disaster: The Solutions We Have and the Breakthroughs We Need. New York and Toronto: Alfred A. Knopf.
Gates, B. (2022). How to Prevent the Next Pandemic. New York and Toronto: Alfred A. Knopf.
Goldberg, D. (2012, June 28). Peter Singer: ‘World’s Most Dangerous Man’ or Hero of Morality? Retrieved June 11, 2023, from The Times of Israel: https://www.timesofisrael.com/peter-singer-worlds-most-dangerous-man-or-hero-of-morality/
Greaves, H., & Pummer, T. (2019). Introduction. In H. Greaves, & T. Pummer (Eds.), Effective Altruism: Philosophical Issues (pp. 1-9). New York: Oxford University Press.
Hakki, T. (2022, March 12). Peter Singer and SBF Talk Crypto's Environmental Impact, Russia-Ukraine, Helping the Unbanked. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from Decrypt: https://decrypt.co/94921/peter-singer-sbf-discuss-crypto-environmental-impact-russia-ukraine-helping-unbanked
Hameiri, S., & Jones, L. (2020). Theorising Political Economy in Southeast Asia. In T. Carroll, S. Hameiri, & L. Jones (Eds.), The Political Economy of Southeast Asia: Politics and Uneven Development under Hyperglobalisation (4th Edition ed., pp. 3-34). Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Harvey, D. (2007). A Brief History of Neoliberalism. New York: Oxford University Press.
Hasani, A. A. (2019, December 31). East Java Farmers Form Credit Union to Break ‘Curse’ of Lifetime Labor This article was published in thejakartapost.com with the title "East Java farmers form credit union to break ‘curse’ of lifetime labor". Click to read: https://www.thejakartapost.com. Retrieved April 20, 2022, from The Jakarta Post: https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2019/12/31/east-java-farmers-form-credit-union-to-break-curse-of-lifetime-labor.html
Hefner, R. W. (2010). Religious Resurgence in Contemporary Asia: Southeast Asian Perspectives on Capitalism, the State, and the New Piety . Journal of Asian Studies, 69(4), 1031-1047.
Henley, D. (2007). Custom and Koperasi: The Co-operative Ideal in Indonesia. In J. S. Davidson, & D. Henley (Eds.), The Revival of Tradition in Indonesian Politics: The Deployment of Adat from Colonialism to Indigenism (pp. 87-112). London and New York: Routledge.
Hoesterey, J. B. (2015). Rebranding Islam: Piety, Prosperity, and a Self-Help Guru. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
IU Lilly Family School of Philanthropy. (2023). Measuring Cross-Border Giving. Retrieved May 26, 2023, from Global Philanthropy Indices: https://globalindices.iupui.edu/tracker/index.html#:~:text=Total%20Cross%2DBorder%20Resources,rises%20to%20USD%20841%20billion.
Jossa, B. (2018). A New Model of Socialism: Democratising Economic Production. Cheltenham and Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Kawano, E. (2021). Solidarity Economy: Building an Economy for People and Planet. In J. G. Speth, & K. Courrier (Eds.), The New Systems Reader: Alternatives to a Failed Economy (pp. 285-301). New York: Routledge.
Latief, H. (2010). Health Provision for the Poor Islamic Aid and the Rise of Charitable Clinics in Indonesia. South East Asia Research, 18(3), 503-553.
Latief, H. (2010). Transforming the Culture of Giving in Indonesia: The Muslim Middle Class, Crisis and Philanthropy. Bulletin of the Nanzan Center for Asia-Pacific Studies, 11(11), 1-21.
Latief, H. (2013). The Politics of Benevolence: Political Patronage of Party-Based Charitable Organizations in Contemporary Indonesian Islam. Al-Jami'ah: Journal of Islamic Studies, 51(2).
Latief, H. (2017). Addressing Unfortunate Wayfarer: Islamic Philanthropy and Indonesian Migrant Workers in Hong Kong. Advances in Southeast Asian Studies, 10(2), 237-255.
Latief, H. (2017). Marketizing Piety through Charitable Work : Islamic Charities and the Islamization of Middle- Class Families in Indonesia. In D. Rudnyckyj, & F. Osella (Eds.), Religion and the Morality of the Market (pp. 196-216). New York: Cambridge University Press.
Lewis-Kraus, G. (2022, December 1). Sam Bankman-Fried, Effective Altruism, and The Question of Complicity. Retrieved June 16, 2023, from The New Yorker: https://www.newyorker.com/news/annals-of-inquiry/sam-bankman-fried-effective-altruism-and-the-question-of-complicity
MacAskill, W. (2015). Doing Good Better: How Effective Altruism Can Help You Make a Difference. New York: Gotham Book.
MacAskill, W. (2017). Effective Altruism: Introduction. Essays in Philosophy, 18(1), 1-5.
MacAskill, W. (2019). The Definition of Effective Altruism. In H. Greaves, & T. Pummer (Eds.), Effective Altruism: Philosophical Issues (pp. 10-28). New York: Oxford University Press.
Malleson, T. (2014). After Occupy: Economic Democracy for the 21st Century. New York: Oxford University Press.
Miller, J. (2023, May 9). Sam Bankman-Fried Asks US Court to Dismiss Criminal Charges over FTX. Retrieved May 29, 2023, from Financial Times: https://www.ft.com/content/bbb43340-2ecb-43e7-8c4e-b563ec92108e
Moloo, Z. (2018, February). The Problem With Capitalist Philanthropy. Retrieved June 19, 2023, from Jacobin: https://jacobin.com/2018/02/charity-philanthropy-howard-buffett-congo
Mudhoffir, A. M. (2022, November 8). Indonesia Demonstrates that Civil Society as a Backbone of Democracy is a Myth. Retrieved June 20, 2023, from Melbourne Asia Review: https://doi.org/10.37839/MAR2652-550X12.4
Ng, Y.-K. (2020). Effective Altruism Despite the Second-best Challenge: Should Indirect Effects be Taken into Account for Policies for a Better Future? Futures, 121, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2020.102568.
Ord, T. (2019). The Moral Imperative Toward Cost-Effectiveness in Global Health. In H. Greaves, & T. Pummer (Eds.), Effective Altruism: Philosophical Issues (pp. 29-36). New York: Oxford University Press.
Ord, T. (2020). The Precipice: Existential Risk and the Future of Humanity. London: Bloomsbury.
Orf, D. (2023, January 18). The Truth About Why Bill Gates Keeps Buying Up So Much Farmland. Retrieved June 19, 2023, from Popular Mechanics: https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/environment/a42543527/why-is-bill-gates-buying-so-much-farmland/
Pontoh, C. H. (2014). Kapitalisme-Neoliberal Sebagai Proyek Kelas: Sebuah Analisis Marxis. Jurnal IndoProgress, 1(1), 1-32.
Pummer, T. (2023). The Rules of Rescue: Cost, Distance, and Effective Altruism. New York: Oxford University Press.
Ranggasari, R. (2022, December 27). Prosecutors Demand 4 Years in Jail for ACT Foundation Corruption Defendants. (L. Afifa, Editor) Retrieved May 28, 2023, from Tempo.co: https://en.tempo.co/read/1672960/prosecutors-demand-4-years-in-jail-for-act-foundation-corruption-defendants
Retsikas, K. (2017). Value Transfers in South East Asia. South East Asia Research, 25(3), 217-233.
Rosana, F. C. (2022, April 3). Baznas: Potensi Zakat di Indonesia Capai Rp 327 Triliun. (A. A. Hidayat, Editor) Retrieved May 25, 2023, from Tempo.co: https://bisnis.tempo.co/read/1578010/baznas-potensi-zakat-di-indonesia-capai-rp-327-triliun
Rudnyckyj, D. (2010). Spiritual Economies: Islam, Globalization, and the Afterlife of Development. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Sanders, B. (2023). How Effective Altruism Fails Community-Based Activism. In C. J. Adams, A. Crary, & L. Gruen (Eds.), The Good It Promises, The Harm It Does: Critical Essays on Effective Altruism (pp. 1-7). New York: Oxford University Press.
Sen, S. (1983). Internationalisation of Capital, Neo-Colonialism and International Finance. Economic and Political Weekly, 18(31), 27-35.
Shiraishi, T. (1990). An Age in Motion: Popular Radicalism in Java, 1912-1926. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Simon, J. (2020). Institutions, Ideologies, and Comparative Political Theory. Perspectives on Politics, 18(2), 423-438.
Singer, P. (1972). Famine, Affluence, and Morality. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 1(3), 229-243.
Singer, P. (2009). An Intellectual Autobiography. In J. A. Schaler (Ed.), Peter Singer Under Fire: The Moral Iconoclast Faces His Critics (pp. 1-74). Chicago and La Salle: Open Court.
Singer, P. (2009). The Life You Can Safe: Acting Now to End World Poverty. New York: Random House.
Singer, P. (2015). The Most Good You Can Do: How Effective Altruism is Changing Ideas about Living Ethically. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
Skinner, Q. (2002). Visions of Politics: Regarding Method. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Snow, M. (2015, August 25). Against Charity. Retrieved June 10, 2023, from Jacobin: https://jacobin.com/2015/08/peter-singer-charity-effective-altruism/
Sommers, M. R. (2022). Dedemocratizing Citizenship: How Neoliberalism Used Market Justice to Move from Welfare Queening to Authoritarianism in 25 Short Years. Citizenship Studies, 26(4-5), 661-674.
Sylla, N. S. (2021). Fighting Monetary Colonialism in Francophone Africa: Samir Amin’s Contribution. Review of African Political Economy, 48(167), 32-49.
Torres, É. P. (2022, December 5). The Grift Brothers: Sam Bankman-Fried, William MacAskill and the Moral Fraud of Effective Altruism. Retrieved June 16, 2023, from Truthdig: https://www.truthdig.com/articles/the-grift-brothers/
UNHCR. (2019, April 26). UNHCR unveils the Refugee Zakat Fund. Retrieved May 26, 2023, from UNHCR Hong Kong: https://www.unhcr.org/hk/en/21723-unhcr-unveils-the-refugee-zakat-fund-a-global-islamic-finance-structure-to-help-displaced-populations-worldwide.html
Vu, T. (2010). Paths to Development in Asia: South Korea, Vietnam, China, and Indonesia. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Weber, I. M. (2021). How China Escaped Shock Therapy: The Market Reform Debate. London and New York: Routledge.
Wiblin, R., & Harris, K. (2018, July 26). Yew-Kwang Ngo on Ethics and How to Create a Much Happier World. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from 80,000 Hours: https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/yew-kwang-ng-anticipating-effective-altruism/
Wilde, O. (1891). The Soul of Man under Socialism. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from Marxists.org: https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/wilde-oscar/soul-man/
Wolff, R. (2012). Democracy at Work: A Cure for Capitalism. Haymarket Books: Chicago.
Wood, E. M. (2008). Citizens to Lords: A Social History of Western Political Thought from Antiquity to the Late Middle Ages. London and New York: Verso.
Wood, N. (1978). The Social History of Political Theory. Political Theory, 6(3), 345-367.
Wright, E. O. (2010). Envisioning Real Utopias. London and New York: Verso.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal. - Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
.png)
