Investment Strategy Trade-Offs in Jakarta Islamic Index Stocks 2006–2025
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17358/ijar.1.2.94Abstract
Background: Systematic investing rules can discipline entry decisions, but their outcomes depend on market conditions, contribution timing, and liquidity.
Purpose: This study compares dollar-cost averaging (DCA), lumpsum investing (LS), and value averaging (VA) in selected Jakarta Islamic Index (JII) stocks.
Methods: A retrospective backtest uses monthly closing prices for seven purposively selected stocks from January 2006 to January 2025. The strategies are evaluated under a common stated nominal budget using annual returns, volatility, paired tests, and risk-adjusted measures, with IHSG as a broad-market reference.
Findings: VA records the highest mean annual return (16.19%), followed by DCA (15.01%) and LS (14.98%), but the return differences are not statistically significant (p = 0.254). DCA has the lowest volatility among the active strategies, while LS achieves the highest cumulative growth among them through earlier market exposure. VA requires flexible contributions and reserve liquidity.
Conclusion: Strategy choice depends on upfront capital availability, tolerance for concentrated entry timing, and the capacity to fund variable contributions.
Originality/value: This long-horizon comparison integrates return, volatility, market exposure, and implementation liquidity in assessing three systematic investment rules for selected Indonesian Sharia equities.
Keywords: dollar-cost averaging, Jakarta Islamic Index, lumpsum investing, risk-adjusted return, value averaging
