A Comparative Analysis of Return Volatility and Its Effect on Stock Returns of Blue-Chip and Non-Blue-Chip
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17358/abq.1.2.88Abstract
Background: Stock return volatility is a key measure of the investment risk that indicates the extent of fluctuation and uncertainty of the stock returns. Investors need to understand volatility when making investment decisions, particularly when assessing the potential risks and returns of different stocks. These considerations are more relevant when considering blue-chip and non-blue-chip stocks, which have different characteristics in terms of market capitalization, liquidity and company fundamentals. These differences may result in differences in return volatility of the two groups and thus their comparative analysis is important to understand the risk characteristics in the capital market.
Purpose: This study is to analyze the differences of return volatility between blue chip stocks represented by LQ45 Index and non-blue chip stocks represented by IDX-SMC Liquid Index, and to examine the effect of volatility on the return in both groups.
Design/methodology/approach: The data used consists of daily closing prices for the period 2020–2025, which are transformed into returns and then modeled using the Generalized Autoregressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity (GARCH) approach to obtain conditional variance (σ²ₜ) as a measure of volatility. The volatility comparison between the two indices is tested using the Mann–Whitney U Test. The analysis of the effect of volatility on returns is conducted through regression by including σ²ₜ as an independent variable.
Findings/Results: The results indicate that the IDX-SMC liquid index exhibits a statistically significant higher level of return volatility compared to the LQ45 index. Furthermore, the regression results show that return volatility has a negative and statistically significant effect on the LQ45 index T+1 period returns at the 10% significance level, but has a positive but statistically insignificant effect on the IDX-SMC Liquid index T+1 period returns.
Conclusion: The results suggest that stock return volatility is a measure of market risk and uncertainty, but not a consistent determinant of daily stock returns. The positive effect of volatility on IDX-SMC Liquid returns is not significant, while the effect of volatility on LQ45 returns is negative and significant at the 10% significance level.The results show the difference of volatility characteristics and the relationship between risk and returns of the two stock indices.
Originality/value (State of the Art): This study adds to the empirical literature by presenting a comparative analysis of return volatility between blue-chip and non-blue-chip stocks in the Indonesian capital market. The LQ45 and IDX-SMC Liquid indices are examined to provide insight into the difference in volatility levels and the relationship between volatility and stock returns in the following period. The results provide a deeper understanding of how volatility characteristics differ across stock categories and the implications for investment risk assessment.
Keywords:
Volatility, stock returns, GARCH, blue chip, non-blue chip, LQ45, IDX-SMC Liquid
