Overhead Cost Share, Material Cost Share, and Profitability: Evidence From Indonesian Listed Textile Firms, 2018–2024
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17358/abq.1.2.97Abstract
Background: Listed Indonesian textile producers lost money in most years between 2018 and 2024, a period of fibre and energy price shocks, the COVID-19 pandemic, weak demand, and import competition. Studies that link production costs to profit mostly use pooled cross-firm variation and report conflicting signs.
Purpose: The study asks whether the composition of production costs (the shares of factory overhead and direct materials, with direct labour as the reference category) is associated with return on assets (ROA), and whether that association differs between firms and within firms over time.
Design/methodology/approach: An unbalanced panel of 11 textile and textile-product firms listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange (76 firm-years) combines hand-collected cost shares from audited annual reports with balance-sheet and income data from LSEG Workspace. Two-way fixed-effect models are estimated with firm-clustered standard errors and wild cluster bootstrap p-values, and a within–between (Mundlak) random-effects model separates the two sources of variation.
Findings/Result: Within firms, the overhead share is negatively associated with ROA at the 10% significance level in every fixed-effects specification: moving one percentage point of the cost base from direct labour to overhead is associated with an ROA about 1.8 percentage points lower. The association loses significance when size and leverage are lagged and disappears once Sri Rejeki Isman, which collapsed in 2021–2022, is excluded. The material share shows no within-firm association. Between-firm and within-firm coefficients differ significantly at the 1% level (joint Mundlak test): firms with structurally higher overhead or material shares are not less profitable on average. All estimates are associations.
Conclusion: In this sample, a rising overhead share goes with lower profitability within firms, but mainly as a signal of severe volume collapse rather than as a general driver of profitability, and pooled estimates of cost composition and profitability mix two different relationships.
Originality/value (State of the art): The study applies the within–between distinction to cost composition in an energy- and asset-intensive industry over the 2018–2024 shock period and shows how sensitive firm-level cost–profit evidence can be to a single distress episode in small listed-firm panels.
Keywords:
cost composition, operating leverage, within–between estimation, profitability, textile industry
